HOME | News | Blogs | Forum | Classifieds | Real Estate | Yellowpages | Jobs | Contact us


Classifieds, Jobs, Yellow Pages, Real Estate, Blogs, Forums
Gandhis Nonviolence gave us Freedom?
India Forum: Comments, Opinion - Information Resource
News Summary: World War II ended in the summer of 1945. In the General Election that followed, Churchill lost to Clement Atlee. With war-torn economy in shambles, Britain was in no shape to hang on to the vast colonial Empire. In March 1946 Atlee agreed to grant independence to India. The following years saw independence granted to many colonies - Burma, Ceylon, Ghana, Malaysia, British Guyana and others that had no history of freedom struggle. So it is correct to conclude that independence to India was a giv.....read more in: Gandhis Nonviolence gave us Freedom?

Add your comments here. We have kept it Simple! No login required, but you must follow the rules below

  
Name      

  • Use PROPER/VALID names: Comments with names like "ABCD", ".." are deleted.
  • Use SAME name EYERY TIME you post. Different named posts by same person (tracked by IPaddress) are deleted.
  • Spammers: Don’t waste your time here. Comments copntaining Commercial/SPAM/Ad words are not listed.
  • Comments containing Website URL will be listed ONLY after review by our Editors (it may take few hours for the review)
  • Comments that include profanity or personal attacks or other inappropriate comments or material not following our Guidelines are deleted from the site. Report Abuse

Comments
        Total 7 Comments     
   


These comments are about: Gandhis Nonviolence gave us Freedom?


SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

SrnoComment on Current Thread            
8 S.Ghosh on Aug-26 :

It is a British propaganda that Gandhi using his Non-Violence method got freedom for India. Only the kindhearted British could appreciate Gandhi and gave India freedom as a generous charitable act. This showed how great the British were.
This is a propaganda, which has nothing to do with the truth. At least 5 million people were forced to starve to death in Bengal in 1943 by the British. Gandhi never said anything about it. At least 300 soldiers of the British Indian Navy were executed after their surrender in 1946 Revolt of the Indian Navy. Gandhi said nothing about that.

Gandhi was imposed upon India by the British Prime Minister Gladstone, who had asked Sir.G.K.Gokhale to import Gandhi to London, train him for 6 months and send him to India to take over The Congress by expelling all other leaders ( Tilak, Lajpat Rai, Surendranath Banerjee, Chittaranjan Das, Bipin Pal, Ajit Singh, Srinivas Iyenger, Anne Besant), and turning Swaraj movement into Khilafat Movement.

7 Vikas on Aug-26 :

KL seetharam, "practice what he preached" ?
This includes sleeping with nude young women
in his experiments in celibacy.

I don"t see him creditworthy of anything.
He was given 5-star treatment and personal secretaries
in jails in contrast to 3rd degree treatment to revolutionaries.
He did not defend or help those who died following non-violence.
He had nothing to criticize British when they killed revolutionaries
and worse, did not acknowledge the sacrifices of revolutionaries of
Mother India. Father of Nation ? No sir, Father of Coterie politics and Democracy breakdown. He humiliated Bose inspite of latter"s win twice
in Congress. Like dirt attracting dirt, he installed womanizing creep Nehru who has destroyed the fabric of this great nation.
To this date India has not recovered from these Tweedledum and Tweedledee villains.
6 klseetharam on Aug-26 :

Mr. Arun Gandhi, the president of now defunct Gandhi Institute of Peace at the University of Rochester, New York has done a mistake. His inclination towards violence is uncalled for. Truly it is a Blunder.
But just the fact that head of Gandhi Institute has done something wrong should not lead to a conclusion that Gandhi(M K Gandhi) was wrong. Just don"t connect these two people. They are very different individuals.

India getting freedom might be due to the political and economical situations existing at that time in Britain, than being due to the freedom fighters of India. But that should not demean the freedom struggle in India at that time and the sacrification done by many of our great leaders like Bhagat Singh. And undoubtedly, Gandhi"s contribution in reaching out to people, uniting them to fight against the injustice done by British is remarkable. He is really the father of our nation.

But as for the question that you have raised - how far nonviolence is successful will remain a question for ever. You can ask this question starting from Gautam Buddha to Mahaveera and all spiritual leaders included.
But throughout the history there is one tested and verified truth. You can not win a victory through violence. NOBODY WINS IN THE WAR. Human generation has to understand it. More so in case of Jehadis and the terrorists.

Lastly, Non-violence was not invented by Gandhi. He just practiced it as his method. Non-violence existed even before human generations existed. So you don"t need to confine a Institute for Non-violence to India alone. It is required to every nation. It may be more needed to India, as you have said it, but it is a universal phenomenon and nobody holds its patent.

Gandhi remains an idol in the history as a man of internal purity. He preached what he practiced. He sacrificed his wordly pleasures because he observed sufferings in his surrounding. That makes him a great soul. And the question "Did India get Independence because of his non-violence movement alone?" sounds less significant.
5 Mo on Aug-22 :

Feedback sent to Author: Did-Gandhi"s-Nonviolence-give-Freedom-to-India?

Indian independence movement was fired up through fearless revolutionaries. The patriotism they evinced from ordinary people got the latter involved in mass movements. This aspect was not understood by Gandhi brigade which hijacked the movement. Gandhi & Co were initially seeking and happy with dominion status. It was Savarkar and Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose and the likes who demanded COMPLETE independence. This sustained pressure resulted in Gandhi taking up 1942 quit india movement, but his movement was a mixed success, no one was quitting. It was the exploits and activities of Subhash Chandra Bose that rattled the British, and their weakened status at WW-II time coupled with Netaji throwing his might and INA with anti-British forces that changed the scene. The existence of INA resulted in potential of mutiny like situation springing any time any where as witnessed at navy at Mumbai. Atlee acknowledged that it was Bose"s activities and WW-II situation that forced British to leave and not Gandhi.
4 nitish on Aug-22 :

excellent. truly rational and sane statement based on facts.
3 Anthony on Nov-05 :

Feedback sent to Author: Did-Gandhi"s-Nonviolence-give-Freedom-to-India?

Very interesting Article. Thank you.

Have you read "The white Tiger?" This book constantly brings up the notion of Gandhi as the face for corruption in India today.

Do you have anything to say to that?

Thank you kindly,

Anthony Sweeting
2 Untraceble on Oct-13 :

India"s people will always ask this question to Gandhiji...

Give us the report of Progress of 16 Years after the death of Great leader Bhagat Singh.. A time when every young guy of the nation was on the road for Freedom...

A popular partimen took india"s fortune for selfishness...




Gandhis Nonviolence gave us Freedom? - Thread over 






Current Threads

Salesman at 20:02 Today : Narendra Modi as Prime Minister - Part I [325 comments]

This Ivarta forum has become a best bulletin board to place personal advertisements. God bless Ivarta moderators!
 Other comments on this post
 forsdocuments85 on Mar-16 : Buy Genuine And Registered Ielts / Toefl / Gre / Gmat without taking exams Skype in.forsdocuments85

 SUCHISMITA RAHA on Feb-26 : Very sadly to write down this about not able exchange my old notes in RBI for during my India visit this jan 2017~ feb 2017 duration. First of all a huge rules of RBI for changing our few amount of notes, which must be passed by custom clearance. Why....
 mukund vaze on Dec-19 : on line ppayments by pos mmachines wpallets etc involves heavy taxes to uusers a small shpop kdeeper have to pay rs 1000 if he ccollected 5000 daily by aTM crads
this is not aaffordable.please make all ppayments free of cost
so that ppeople ....
DrRichardD on Mar-08 : Thoughts on Jati-Varna System [13 comments]

We are urgently in need of kidney donors for the sum of $409,000.00, Contact us now on email for more details.WHATS APP MESSAGE ONLY plus 917411484388
PHONE CALL plus 917411484388
drrichard803@gmail.com
We are located in India
Dr. Richard D
 Other comments on this post
 Brete Pete on Feb-28 : ATTN
THIS MESSAGE IS PARTICULARLY FOR THOSE IN NEED OF THE CANNABIS OIL.PLEASE GET IN TOUCH

Our Cannabis Oil is Pure and potent.Never watered down or diluted,just 100 pure cannabis oil extracted from top quality marijuana grown by us and....
Brete Pete on Feb-28 : Who will clean garbage at Ashram? [2 comments]

ATTN
THIS MESSAGE IS PARTICULARLY FOR THOSE IN NEED OF THE CANNABIS OIL.PLEASE GET IN TOUCH

Our Cannabis Oil is Pure and potent.Never watered down or diluted,just 100 pure cannabis oil extracted from top quality marijuana grown by us and other professional cultivators in California,laboratory tested,then offered

freely here o....
Brete Pete on Feb-28 : Nava-Ratri-Celebration or Exhibitionism? [10 comments]

ATTN
THIS MESSAGE IS PARTICULARLY FOR THOSE IN NEED OF THE CANNABIS OIL.PLEASE GET IN TOUCH

Our Cannabis Oil is Pure and potent.Never watered down or diluted,just 100 pure cannabis oil extracted from top quality marijuana grown by us and other professional cultivators in California,laboratory tested,then offered

freely here o....
 Other comments on this post
 katherine on Oct-22 : Reflect the beam of your love into the lives of your dear ones by sending them these stunning arrangements of Flowers. Send Flowers to Paris through various online stores for your dear ones for whom you really care.
 Mo on Jun-10 : Good article. Introspection is needed. But will it reach those who are bound to hurt and trouble the next woman they find ?
Brete Pete on Feb-28 : NYT corrects Modi editorial blunders [8 comments]

ATTN
THIS MESSAGE IS PARTICULARLY FOR THOSE IN NEED OF THE CANNABIS OIL.PLEASE GET IN TOUCH

Our Cannabis Oil is Pure and potent.Never watered down or diluted,just 100 pure cannabis oil extracted from top quality marijuana grown by us and other professional cultivators in California,laboratory tested,then offered

freely here o....
 Other comments on this post
 cakenchocolates1 on Feb-07 : More people now-a-days prefer online shopping over conventional shopping. An e-commerce facility has opened a new pathway through different online stores online stores. These kinds of online transactions are very safe, secure and confidential. Delive....
Brete Pete on Feb-28 : A prayer for Narendra Modi [18 comments]

ATTN
THIS MESSAGE IS PARTICULARLY FOR THOSE IN NEED OF THE CANNABIS OIL.PLEASE GET IN TOUCH

Our Cannabis Oil is Pure and potent.Never watered down or diluted,just 100 pure cannabis oil extracted from top quality marijuana grown by us and other professional cultivators in California,laboratory tested,then offered

freely here o....
 Other comments on this post
 Prasanta Roy on Jan-24 : Send this classic collection of exotic flowers to the dear ones who would rejoice the gifts which are especially delivered from the bottom of one"s heart. Flowers are the ultimate gifts which are gifted only to please the close friends and co~relativ....
 Saibal Roy on Feb-11 : Valentine"s Day marks the occasion where love flows in the air and adds a spark in the heart of your love. During this day every lover has an urge to Send Valentine"s Day Cakes to India, so that in India every girl gets an opportunity to enjoy this m....
 Anik Roy on May-06 : Tryout something unique and special by presenting Flowers and Gifts on mother"s day that represents the message of your soul. Send Mother"s Day Flowers to Japan and appreciate your mother for the special feelings that she has brought to your life. Or....





Comments (till the day of this story)
Kishore on Aug-25 : Book Review: Understanding Muhammad [21 comments]

There is another great book by Craig Wynn called "The prophet of doom". It is a free book available both in print and audio on his website prophetofdoom.org - otherwise just google it. I recommend the book strongly. He proves beyond doubt that the Koran is a terrorist manifesto and lays bare mohammeds unsavoury lifestyle. Imagine a "prophet" reachi....
hindu on Aug-13 : Vedic, Aztec & Mayan Culture [7 comments]

culinary similarities -indians have roti and rajma(beans)and south americans have tortilla and beans-defeats conventional thinking about civilisation and its development
Rasik Sanghvi on Aug-08 : Traveling Sunlit Path or Encouraging... [4 comments]

It is unclear what Lori is objecting to Deshpandey. Sri Aurobindo is mentioning very limited numeric numbers in cycle of sacrificial 12 months times two and aperiod of total 10 months. How can that justify diverting to fullsome numerology and cosmology except for limited discussion of accurately identifying the period in the context of present prac....
A.Moron on Aug-12 : Afghan Problem and How Not to Solve it [13 comments]

I fear for India. With such a low grade leadership, India is about to give up Kashmir to satisfy Obama and Osama.
S.Ghosh on Aug-11 : Greek Tragedy and its lessons [2 comments]

Indiam PM and his economists are only interested to satisfy Western companies and banks. They do not care about us.

Anup on Aug-04 : Wendy Doniger Book - History or Porn? [12 comments]

Another Jew like Wendy is after Hindus now. If interested please see article in VOI newsletter 01 Aug 2010-Joel Stein attacks Hinduism and Hindus.
S.Ghosh on May-27 : Hussain, Nithyananda, Media & Deception [9 comments]

It is essential not to pass judgement in these matters. A lot of Hindu Guru Maharajs, Mohantas, Swamis are only money-hungry, sex-hungry cheats. They hardly know anything about Hindu religion.

Do not forget Bhagwan Rajnish. There are many like him in this Guru business.
David on Aug-04 : Koran, Amsterdam and Calcutta Court [184 comments]

Hindus go thru useless arguments with Moslim (read illogical, empty headed)to convince them how peaceful and benevolent Hindus are (read cowards, gutless and sell anything for Roti, Kapadaa and Makaan). That conversation proves totally useless and going nowhere. Need guts to expose true face of Islam and its third rate messenger"s private life...to....
ganesh on Jul-18 : Attack On Swami Nityanada [28 comments]

Personnaly, I think if someone prevents a generous man from giving food to poor people or if he prevents someone from giving frre education to poor children or if someone prevents another suffering human being to benefit from free medical assistance or if someone prevents a old man to get a shelter and food or if somone breaks a couple and seperate....
Dr. Ratan Bhattachar on May-07 : Wars Are Drugs [3 comments]

Dont know why Pakistan is inciting people to wage war against India. Neighbourly relations if they are smooth and peaceful, will reduce the budgetary cost. Pakistan should stop trying to win over India by sending Kasavs but by showing friendly relations in commerce and industry. Defence cost will be nearly half if Pakistan feels that it is a frien....


 

Gandhis Nonviolence gave us Freedom?
India Forum: Comments, Opinion, - Information Resource

Copyright and Disclaimer:
The views expressed in this forum are of the People/Visitors/Authors who post them and not of this website. The author is solely responsible for the contents of the Posts/Views/Opinions on this Discussion Board, Forums. This website does not represent or endorse the accuracy, completeness or reliability of any opinion, statement, appeal, advice or any other information in the Forum Posts. Our readers are free to forward this forum page URL to anyone. This forum posts may NOT be transmitted or distributed by others in any manner whatsoever (other than forwarding or web listing page URL) without the prior permission from this website.

India Varta iVarta.com

Visit iVarta.com for Classifieds, Yellow Pages, and Business Networking 

Free Classified and Yellowpages Listing
Americas Best Classified and Yellowpage Search Engine
Post Asia UK Canada America USA and India classifieds FREE
Reach Worldwide Community by listing your posting at iVarta Open Directory
Terms of Service | Join mailing list