HOME | News | Blogs | Forum | Classifieds | Real Estate | Yellowpages | Jobs | Contact us

Classifieds, Jobs, Yellow Pages, Real Estate, Blogs, Forums
Book Review: Understanding Muhammad
India Forum: Comments, Opinion - Information Resource
News Summary: A large section of Muslims created hullabaloo recently for banning of Dr. Zakir Naik from entering UK. "Hes banned for having spoken the truth." many Muslims along with their apologists assert. "See he has proved the supremacy of Islam in front of several religious leaders." This idea of having "proved the supremacy of Islam" for these Muslims is little more than showing down upon others faith by concocted ideas and theories. That Dr. Naik thrives by demeaning gods and prophets of other faiths i.....read more in: Book Review: Understanding Muhammad

Add your comments here. We have kept it Simple! No login required, but you must follow the rules below


  • Use PROPER/VALID names: Comments with names like "ABCD", ".." are deleted.
  • Use SAME name EYERY TIME you post. Different named posts by same person (tracked by IPaddress) are deleted.
  • Spammers: Don’t waste your time here. Comments copntaining Commercial/SPAM/Ad words are not listed.
  • Comments containing Website URL will be listed ONLY after review by our Editors (it may take few hours for the review)
  • Comments that include profanity or personal attacks or other inappropriate comments or material not following our Guidelines are deleted from the site. Report Abuse

        Total 21 Comments     

These comments are about: Book Review: Understanding Muhammad

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

SrnoComment on Current Thread            
23 A.Moron on Sep-05 :

It is only natural for any King, Sultan to shout from the top of his palace that "I am the God; wash my feet, otherwise I will cut your head off".
Akber started a new religion; Japanese Emperors used to think that they were Gods. That is the way Muslim religion had started.

22 A.Moron on Sep-05 :

Zakir Naik is Indian. Indians allow him to stay in India but propagate against India"s heriatage. Thus type of Panipath mentality of the Hindus are responsible for the defeat of the Hindus.

Wake up man. Muslim want you to surrender, change your religion, eat beef, go to Haj. If you do not do that, they will cut off your neck.

21 Daksha on Sep-04 :

All the hindus in general and myself in particular should learn to respect other religions from muslims only(sic). Hindus respect all the religions and muslims do not even recognize hinduism, Budhism and Taoism. They have lip service of respect for Chirstianity and Judaism. All muslims needs a leader like Gorobochev who will admit islam have flaws and needs to fixed. Muslims looking for godly help and humanly handouts. Within the Muslims they need to bridge between Shias and Sunnis. They are yet to lay a ground work for reconcilliation. Instead of blaming others for their misery they should start restropective and introspection.
20 Daksha on Sep-04 :

To Kurbi
As a hindu we are not in a state of denial of our flaws, whereas, muslims are in state of denial of any flaws in their system. Through out the world Muslims have problem with rest of the communities. In Britain, Indians and pakistanis went with same socio economic background and now see the success of second generation hindus and compare with second generation Muslims. As a hindu we do not have any problem in assimalting in other cultures. Hinduism contributed, Ayurveda, Yoga, Meditation, Dance, Music, Logic, zero and mathematics. I live in USA, Indians are the most educated and richest among all the immigrants. Tell me a country Muslims do not have any problems with the rest of the community. Kurbi please contradict me in facts not on flaws. Muslims have a habit of blaming everybody else and do not take any responsibilites. All the muslim countries are depending on foreign aid and oil money. More hindus won noble prizes In sciences than Mulims with 1.5 Billion Population. Among Muslims, I am yet to see Gandhi, Martin Luther King and Nelson Mandela. You compare the religious Leaders of hinduism, such as, Vivekananda, Ramana Maharshi, Dayananada Saraswati with Shahi Imam Abudullah Bukhari, Tantavi of Egypt and you will get the answer. All the muslim religious leaders talk nothing but thrash. All muslims know is how to distroy the civilization. Thoroughout the History, Hindusm contribution to the world is more than all the religions in the world combined. Muslims went to Iran and distroyed ancient religion, zorastrasim.
19 kurbi on Sep-04 :

Mr./Ms Daksha
Learn to respect other religions. Our own hindu has got numerous flaws.
Mind it.
16 Kishore on Aug-25 :

There is another great book by Craig Wynn called "The prophet of doom". It is a free book available both in print and audio on his website prophetofdoom.org - otherwise just google it. I recommend the book strongly. He proves beyond doubt that the Koran is a terrorist manifesto and lays bare mohammeds unsavoury lifestyle. Imagine a "prophet" reaching out to accept his share of stolen goods of raisins, leather goods, dates and mats made by hard working traders and then salving his conscience by saying - god said its okay for muslims to steal from kafirs.
15 gabbar on Aug-22 :

Daksha don"t ask that question otherwise the sun will set in the muddy pool...
14 Daksha on Aug-21 :

The difference between moderate muslim and fundamentalistic Muslim is the size of beard. Throughout the world muslims as majority or as a minority they are behind the rest of the community. I would like to ask muslims if earth is round or flat. If it is round you can face any side and face Makkah.
13 Anup on Aug-19 :

There is an interesting article by Ayesha Ahmed;"Sex with daughters-in-law;Divinely ordained Islam". It is on google.
As regards the lady devotee asking Muhammad about her adopted son, I am not sure whether it was mentioned he was an adult. I have not got the book with me at the moment.
12 gabbar on Aug-19 :

"Muhammad"s first wife ( he had about 22 legal wife during his lifetime )Khalida was a businesswoman.She had male employees working for her. She must have spoken to them but Muhammad did not kill her."

I think she was Khadiza. At that time Muhammad was not strong enough to do that. In his earlier life he wanted support and wealth from the lady and hence he could not dictate his terms.
11 Anup on Aug-18 :

Ali Sina made his mind up to write this book after watching how a Pakistani burnt his wife to death. Her crime was she was seen speaking to her cousin.
Muhammad"s first wife ( he had about 22 legal wife during his lifetime )Khalida was a businesswoman.She had male employees working for her. She must have spoken to them but Muhammad did not kill her.
I find it quite intriguing that angel Gabriel, a biblical angel spoke to him.Muhammad used to attend a fair every year where Christian priests used to preach.My guess is, he probably heard about the angel from the Christian priests.

When he could not resist the temptation of having her daughter-in-law in bed with her, he declared via Allah, all adoptions as invalid, as this woman was his adopted son"s wife.
A lady devotee asked the prophethow could she discard her adopted adult son, whom she loved so much.
Muhammad found a solution for her. He asked her to breastfeed her adopted adult son-by doing so he would become a naturalson.
Recently Ali Sina stated thatthe top Americanswho agreed to allow Muslims to build a mosque or Islamic centre may have been bribed by saudi Arabia(a close friend of "secular" India)and /or Iran as has happened in the past.
I wonder, whether similar sorts of activities are taking place in India.
Unfortunately Sonia government won"t allow us to see which Indians got all the money held in Swiss banks.
10 Daksha on Aug-13 :

India is building greatest institution,that is, IIT(Indian Institute of Technology) and whereas muslims build the greatest Institution, that is Islamic Institute of terrorism. The islam instituionalized terrorism.
9 Sandra on Aug-13 :

And growing beard doesn"t need any intelligence or hard-work.
8 Daksha on Aug-13 :

If muslims are minority they do not go along with majority and they adovocate Geneva Conventions. If muslims are in majority there are no minorities and they want laws based on sharia. This is a typical example of hypocracy. Througout the world muslims are known for backwardness. All they know is how to grow beard.
7 Jai on Aug-12 :

Daksha,Maha Mad only used the word Allah just to get out of sticky situations--any cul de sac route taken it is Insallah.
6 Daksha on Aug-11 :

Islam is not a religon but militant cult lacks any logic and reasoning. Muslims do not go along with any religion. They do not go along with Hindus, Cristians, Jews, Budhists and Parsi religion. They have problem with everybody in the world. Genrally muslims families are disfunctional. All they know is how to create problem with the rest of the world. All the islamic countries have only 450 universities. India have 8300 Universities. The greatest contributions and inventions of muslims are Car Bombing, Hijacking Planes and creative distruction.
5 Daksha on Aug-10 :

I recommend everybody to go into following websites.

These are the websites created by Ex-Muslims. These website gives indepth nature of islam. If muslims are in majority in any country, then there are no minorites and they want Shariyat. If muslims are in Minority, they donot go along with majority and they demand Genewa Conventions. It is a typical example of Hypocracy. In the past, Iran was invaded by islamic forces. TaTa came to India and prospered. Had he would had been in Iran, he will growing beard and issuing useless fatwas. It is shame that all the islamic countries are either depending on oil, that is rent from earth or depending on foreign aid. Muslims when they meed, they eat and then critisize all the religions and issue useless fatwas.
4 Daksha on Aug-10 :

Kudos to Ali Sina for writing a great book. Kudos to Prabhu for excellent review. You should also review books like Islamic Slavery by MK Khan. Islam is not a religion but militant cult. Somebody should take initiative to translate into various indian languages including urdu.
3 Guru Charan on Aug-10 :

Feedback sent to Author: Book-Review:-Understanding-Muhammad

Dear Shri. Mahesh Prabhu,

Thank you for doing a great service to the world and India in particular by reviewing the book on Prophet Muhammed. Slowly, the world is coming to know about the truths of totalitarian ideologies like Islam. Your review has given a boost to this world wide awakening to the truth of Islam. India is not without its heroes in this regard. Shri Sita Ram Goel and Shri. Ram Swarup have done yeoman service in this regard. That is why you don"t find their names mentioned in the known intellectual circles. Because they were the pioneers who discovered that all monotheistic creeds were totalitarian. Add to this group communism, fascism and the rest. They are basically the same ideas
packaged differently. All of them want to control the people by lure or by force. All of them don"t want the people to think for themselves or differ with them. Somewhere Shri. Ram Swarup says "Islam, Christianity, Communism and Nazism are the greatest tragedies of humanity". How true indeed! And we make the monumental blunder of equating these ideologies with Sanatana Dharma which is so totally and radically different than these totalitarian creeds. It is heartening to see that at least a few courageous people are awakening to the truth and see it for what it is.

Thanks a lot for your review. Also about your article about the RSS, what you write is so true. The RSS lost it long ago when a man as great as Guruji Golwalkar said that Islam was compatible with Hindutva. Now you decide. No wonder the Gadkaris, the Vajpayees and Advanis are out to appease muslims and calling the Congress and other parties pseudo-secularists. The bane of RSS and its affiliates is the lack of intellectual acumen. The malady with the RSS was rightfully diagnosed by Shri. Sita Ram Goel. That is why he was pushed out of the Organizer.

I have no hopes for the Hindu society from the RSS.


2 Rajagopalan Seshadri on Aug-05 :

I have read both the English and Tamil versions of this book. I find that the Tamil Book with the Translator"s comments at appropriate places is worth keeping in mind and to be best thing that happened to Tamil speaking people. This Tamil version is also the true Translation of it original. I am also surprised that it is translated by an ex-Muslim lady called Mona Malik Mustafa. I wish every one in Tamil Nadu reads the Tamil book so that they can realise that how they are supporting a wrong cult, ably assisted by Dravida Kazhagams of Tamil Nadu, who have no permanent democatic norms and real turn coats and hats. The whole Indian nation is going to dogs only for supporting the appeasement of this cult people and encouraging the regional parties like DMK.
I have no regret about pronouncing so, without any mental reservation.

More Comment Pages: 1 2

Book Review: Understanding Muhammad - Thread over 

Current Threads

v g subramanian at 03:52 Today : The Kashmir Problem and its solution [94 comments]

 Other comments on this post
 Palvi on May-10 : Both can cooperate and can use it as a tourist place it would be beneficial for both the countries

 UJJWAL KARMAKAR on Sep-12 : The best thing is don"t solve it.Time will solve it.Give it one hundred years more, and a solution will be there.
Austinvap on Sunday : Islamic Fanaticism, No Economic Backw.. [16 comments]

Feedback sent to Author: J

???????? ?? ?????????? (Huaxin Breast Plaster)
- ??? ??????????? ? ?????????? ?????? ???????
? ???????????? ??????????? ??????? ?????.

???????? ???????? ????????
?? ???????? ????????? ????????? ??????????? ????.

«????????? ??????????????? ???????? «HUAXIN BREAST PLASTER»
 Other comments on this post
 ?????? on Saturday : Feedback sent to Author: J

?????? ???????
 WalterMof on May-15 : Feedback sent to Author: J

????????? ?????????? ????? ???????????? ??????????
? ALCOVIRIN ?????? ?????? ?? ???????!

??? ?????? ????????? ???????????? ????????, ?????????????? ????????? ??????????????? ???????? ??? ?????????? ....
 WalterMof on May-15 : Feedback sent to Author: J

????????? ?????????? ????? ???????????? ??????????
? ALCOVIRIN ?????? ?????? ?? ???????!

??? ?????? ????????? ???????????? ????????, ?????????????? ????????? ??????????????? ???????? ??? ?????????? ....
Ocean offshore marin on Friday : 1200 Comments: Open letter to Mr.SRK [1 comments]

Ocean Offshore Marine India
Call for offshore course and cdc

Ocean Offshore Marine India trains the budding Merchant Navy sailors and the promising Offshore professionals in a way not imagined by even the best minds of the world. We challenge the human imagination and redefine the parameters. Where there is no space for the courses, w....
Dr Richard on May-10 : Won"t Settle for Slogans Like "Indians for Indi.. [1 comments]

We are urgently in need of kidney donors for the sum of $409,000.00, Contact us now on email for more details.WHATS APP MESSAGE ONLY plus 917411484388 PHONE CALL plus 919739098941 drrichard803@gmail.com We are located in India Dr. Richard D
Pushan Roy on Apr-11 : A prayer for Narendra Modi [23 comments]

Flowers are the most stunning items which are occasionally presented on every occasion to make the people happy. Florists are the people who deal with the flowers and discover new floral designs which attract more people towards this. The cities like, Chandigarh, Mohali, Panchkula has a huge demand of flowers and hence florists plays a vital role. ....
 Other comments on this post
 Brete Pete on Feb-28 : ATTN

Our Cannabis Oil is Pure and potent.Never watered down or diluted,just 100 pure cannabis oil extracted from top quality marijuana grown by us and....
 Expresscare on Dec-23 : Thanks to share with us your information.. It will make togetherness among the people through the online shopping sites. but modi is a great....such a great article I am sharing your article,...
 Saibal Roy on Feb-11 : Valentine"s Day marks the occasion where love flows in the air and adds a spark in the heart of your love. During this day every lover has an urge to Send Valentine"s Day Cakes to India, so that in India every girl gets an opportunity to enjoy this m....
Rushi patel on Apr-06 : Narendra Modi as Prime Minister - Part I [331 comments]

All ATM out of oder why?

 Other comments on this post
 Rushi patel on Apr-06 : All ATM out of oder why?

 Francoisservice on Apr-03 : Hello The whole group
To settle your debts, bills and other financial problems, no more worries.
For all your loan or investment requests, do not hesitate. Please contact this financing agency to be satisfied.
They are also in the area of....
 Salesman on Mar-24 : This Ivarta forum has become a best bulletin board to place personal advertisements. God bless Ivarta moderators!

Comments (till the day of this story)
Daksha on Sep-04 : Book Review: Understanding Muhammad [21 comments]

All the hindus in general and myself in particular should learn to respect other religions from muslims only(sic). Hindus respect all the religions and muslims do not even recognize hinduism, Budhism and Taoism. They have lip service of respect for Chirstianity and Judaism. All muslims needs a leader like Gorobochev who will admit islam have flaw....
hindu on Aug-13 : Vedic, Aztec & Mayan Culture [7 comments]

culinary similarities -indians have roti and rajma(beans)and south americans have tortilla and beans-defeats conventional thinking about civilisation and its development
Rasik Sanghvi on Aug-08 : Traveling Sunlit Path or Encouraging... [4 comments]

It is unclear what Lori is objecting to Deshpandey. Sri Aurobindo is mentioning very limited numeric numbers in cycle of sacrificial 12 months times two and aperiod of total 10 months. How can that justify diverting to fullsome numerology and cosmology except for limited discussion of accurately identifying the period in the context of present prac....
A.Moron on Aug-12 : Afghan Problem and How Not to Solve it [13 comments]

I fear for India. With such a low grade leadership, India is about to give up Kashmir to satisfy Obama and Osama.
S.Ghosh on Aug-11 : Greek Tragedy and its lessons [2 comments]

Indiam PM and his economists are only interested to satisfy Western companies and banks. They do not care about us.

Anup on Aug-04 : Wendy Doniger Book - History or Porn? [12 comments]

Another Jew like Wendy is after Hindus now. If interested please see article in VOI newsletter 01 Aug 2010-Joel Stein attacks Hinduism and Hindus.
S.Ghosh on May-27 : Hussain, Nithyananda, Media & Deception [9 comments]

It is essential not to pass judgement in these matters. A lot of Hindu Guru Maharajs, Mohantas, Swamis are only money-hungry, sex-hungry cheats. They hardly know anything about Hindu religion.

Do not forget Bhagwan Rajnish. There are many like him in this Guru business.
David on Aug-04 : Koran, Amsterdam and Calcutta Court [184 comments]

Hindus go thru useless arguments with Moslim (read illogical, empty headed)to convince them how peaceful and benevolent Hindus are (read cowards, gutless and sell anything for Roti, Kapadaa and Makaan). That conversation proves totally useless and going nowhere. Need guts to expose true face of Islam and its third rate messenger"s private life...to....
ganesh on Jul-18 : Attack On Swami Nityanada [28 comments]

Personnaly, I think if someone prevents a generous man from giving food to poor people or if he prevents someone from giving frre education to poor children or if someone prevents another suffering human being to benefit from free medical assistance or if someone prevents a old man to get a shelter and food or if somone breaks a couple and seperate....
Dr. Ratan Bhattachar on May-07 : Wars Are Drugs [3 comments]

Dont know why Pakistan is inciting people to wage war against India. Neighbourly relations if they are smooth and peaceful, will reduce the budgetary cost. Pakistan should stop trying to win over India by sending Kasavs but by showing friendly relations in commerce and industry. Defence cost will be nearly half if Pakistan feels that it is a frien....


Book Review: Understanding Muhammad
India Forum: Comments, Opinion, - Information Resource

Copyright and Disclaimer:
The views expressed in this forum are of the People/Visitors/Authors who post them and not of this website. The author is solely responsible for the contents of the Posts/Views/Opinions on this Discussion Board, Forums. This website does not represent or endorse the accuracy, completeness or reliability of any opinion, statement, appeal, advice or any other information in the Forum Posts. Our readers are free to forward this forum page URL to anyone. This forum posts may NOT be transmitted or distributed by others in any manner whatsoever (other than forwarding or web listing page URL) without the prior permission from this website.

India Varta iVarta.com

Visit iVarta.com for Classifieds, Yellow Pages, and Business Networking 

Free Classified and Yellowpages Listing
Americas Best Classified and Yellowpage Search Engine
Post Asia UK Canada America USA and India classifieds FREE
Reach Worldwide Community by listing your posting at iVarta Open Directory
Terms of Service | Join mailing list